10 Questions to Ask Before Hiring an AEO/AI SEO Agency - MacRAE'S ...
Mon–Fri, 9:00–17:00 EST1-877-629-6104

10 Questions to Ask Before Hiring an AEO/AI SEO Agency

10 Questions to Ask Before Hiring an AEO/AI SEO Agency

AI tools now answer many buyer questions before anyone clicks a link. ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and Google’s AI Overviews summarize vendors, compare options, and sometimes hand buyers a shortlist. That shift has produced a wave of new providers. Not every one has changed its methods, so buyers need a clear way to vet an AI SEO agency.
People Also Ask

What does an AI SEO agency do?

It helps AI search tools and search engines understand, trust, and cite a business. The work covers content structure, entities, technical SEO, and authority building.

What is the difference between AEO and AI SEO?

AEO focuses on getting content selected as the direct answer to a question. AI SEO is broader and covers how AI systems interpret, summarize, and recommend a brand.

Is AI SEO different from traditional SEO?

Yes, but it builds on it. Traditional SEO targets keyword rankings. AI SEO adds entity clarity, answer-ready content, and the trust signals AI systems rely on.
The right questions separate a provider with a real method from one that has renamed its old SEO package. The ten below cover strategy, measurement, content, technical work, and fit. They let buyers compare every provider on a level playing field. For more context, see how an AI SEO agency gets a business found in AI search. Before the questions, it helps to understand why AI visibility matters and what to prepare internally. Buyers with clear goals and a realistic budget get more useful answers from every agency.

Why AI Search Visibility Matters for B2B Companies

B2B buyers research quietly. Engineers, procurement teams, and plant managers often compare suppliers long before they contact sales. More of that research now happens inside AI tools. Instead of scanning a page of links, a buyer asks one question. The AI tool returns one answer that names a handful of companies. In February 2024, Gartner predicted traditional search engine volume would drop 25% by 2026. It expected users to shift to AI chatbots and virtual agents. Whatever the final figure, the direction is clear. A business missing from AI answers misses a growing share of early-stage research. For industrial and technical companies, the stakes are higher. AI tools often describe a supplier using whatever information is easiest to find. That may be an outdated directory listing or a competitor’s comparison page. A deliberate AI SEO strategy gives a business more control over how it is described and recommended.

What to Do Before Hiring an AI SEO Agency

A short internal review before the first sales call makes every conversation more productive. It also helps you avoid a provider that forces a buyer’s needs into a standard package.

Define What AI Visibility Should Do for the Business

Decide whether the priority is brand awareness, qualified leads, RFQs, distributor inquiries, or reputation management. Each goal requires a different mix of content, technical work, and measurement. A capable agency builds its plan around that goal.

Set a Realistic Budget

AI SEO usually layers onto an ongoing SEO program rather than being bought as a one-off project. Plan for continuing work, including content production, technical fixes, and monitoring across several AI platforms. A budget that only covers an audit will identify problems without funding the fixes.

Check the Starting Point

Ask ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity the questions buyers ask. Examples include which suppliers make a certain product, which companies serve an industry, or how two vendors compare. Note whether the business appears, how it is described, and which competitors are named instead. That quick test sets a baseline for checking every agency’s claims.

Build a Shortlist

When comparing providers, look for:
  • Proven work in B2B or industrial markets, not only ecommerce or local services
  • A documented process that starts with research rather than a fixed package
  • Sample reports available for review before signing
  • A clear line between traditional SEO results and AI visibility results
With that groundwork done, bring these ten questions to every agency conversation.

1. How Does the Agency Define AEO, GEO, and AI SEO?

A provider should explain these terms in plain language and show how they connect. Answer engine optimization targets direct answers. Generative engine optimization targets how large language models summarize and recommend brands. AI SEO ties both to a traditional search foundation. Listen for how the provider links the three in practice. A strong answer explains each role. AEO shapes content into clear, extractable answers. GEO strengthens the brand signals and sources that language models draw from. AI SEO keeps both tied to crawlable, well-ranked pages. Some providers also cover LLM for SEO. It focuses on how models such as ChatGPT and Claude describe a brand. Vague or interchangeable definitions are a warning sign. A team that can’t separate the disciplines usually can’t plan for them separately either.

2. Which AI Platforms Will the Agency Track?

ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, Copilot, and Google AI Overviews each pull sources in their own way. Ask which platforms the provider covers, how often it tests prompts, and whether prompts reflect real buyer questions. The differences matter. Google AI Overviews leans heavily on pages that already perform well in organic search. Perplexity shows its sources openly and refreshes them often. Depending on the question, ChatGPT may draw on live web results or on what the model already knows. A provider should explain how its approach changes across platforms instead of treating them as one channel. A manufacturer needs prompts built around specifications, applications, and supplier comparisons. Generic brand-name checks won’t show where deals are being won or lost. Ask to see the prompt list itself; a good one reads like real buyer questions. Here is how we handle it. We track visibility across Google, Bing, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, LinkedIn, and the industry directories industrial buyers rely on. We also test our AI SEO methods on our own platforms before using them for clients. Those platforms are Scott’s Directories and the Canadian Trade Index.

3. How Will the Agency Measure Success?

Rankings and traffic still matter, but they no longer tell the full story. Useful AI visibility metrics include brand mentions, citation frequency, and share of voice against named competitors. Another is how accurately AI tools describe the business. A useful AI visibility report typically covers:
  • Mentions: how often the brand appears in AI answers for target prompts
  • Citations: which of the business’s pages are referenced as sources
  • Share of voice: how often the brand appears compared with named competitors
  • Accuracy: whether AI tools describe products, services, and locations correctly
  • Business impact: referral traffic from AI platforms, leads, and RFQs
Business impact deserves extra weight. Visibility that never turns into inquiries is a vanity metric. Ask how the provider connects AI visibility to pipeline. Ask to see a sample report. If it only lists keyword positions, the measurement model hasn’t caught up with the service being sold.

4. Does the Agency Start With an Audit and Competitor Gap Analysis?

A credible program first finds where a business appears in AI answers, where competitors appear instead, and why. Skip this step and the strategy rests on guesswork. A thorough audit should review:
  • Current mentions and citations across the major AI platforms
  • Which competitors appear for priority buyer questions, and the likely reasons
  • Technical health, including crawlability, site speed, and schema markup
  • Content gaps where buyers ask questions the site doesn’t answer
  • Entity consistency across the website, directories, and industry platforms
Ask how long the audit takes and what the final deliverable includes. A clear deliverable with prioritized recommendations is a good sign. A one-page summary followed immediately by a retainer proposal is not. This is where we start every program. Our process moves from a visibility audit to a competitor gap analysis. Content and technical remediation, authority building, and ongoing monitoring follow. Each stage feeds the next, so our recommendations come from evidence rather than a template.

5. How Will the Agency Handle Entity and Structured Data Work?

AI systems form a picture of a business from entities. These include what it is, what it makes, and which industries it serves. They also include how those facts connect across the web. Schema markup, consistent naming, and clear service definitions all sharpen that picture. Inconsistency is a frequent problem. Picture a company listed under three slightly different names. Its website, LinkedIn page, and industry directories describe its services differently. That sends AI tools mixed signals. The result can be an inaccurate description or no mention at all. Ask how the provider audits entity signals and fixes inconsistencies. That includes the directories and professional platforms AI tools use to verify credibility. A good answer names specific schema types, such as Organization, Product, Service, and FAQ markup. It also explains how entity data stays consistent after the first fixes.

6. What Does the Agency’s Content Approach Look Like?

AI tools favor content that answers specific questions clearly, in passages that make sense on their own. Ask whether the provider writes question-led sections, FAQs, and comparison content, and who checks technical accuracy. Request writing samples from the same industry. AI-ready content usually includes:
  • A direct answer near the top of each section
  • Headings that match how buyers phrase their searches and prompts
  • Specific details such as materials, tolerances, certifications, and applications
  • Comparison tables and FAQs that AI tools can extract cleanly
For industrial and technical companies, accuracy beats volume. A large volume of generic posts rarely earns the citations that one well-structured application guide can. Technical buyers notice errors quickly, and AI tools can repeat them. Confirm that someone reviews content before it goes live.

7. Will the Agency Keep the Traditional SEO Foundation Strong?

AI systems lean on the same authority and relevance signals search engines use. Crawlability, site speed, internal linking, and backlinks still determine whether search engines can find and surface a site’s content. Organic rankings and AI visibility often move together. When AI tools search the web, they favor pages that rank well, load quickly, and earn quality backlinks. Some providers treat AI SEO as a replacement for SEO rather than an extension. That approach skips the groundwork AI visibility depends on. Ask how the work is split between the two and whether one team owns both. Separate teams working in isolation often make conflicting changes to the same pages.

8. Can the Agency Show Results for Similar B2B Businesses?

Ask for case studies in similar industries, with named clients where possible. Check whether each result reflects AI visibility or traditional SEO. Note whether the provider labels the difference honestly. Industry fit matters too. Long sales cycles, multiple decision-makers, and technical buyer language call for a different playbook than consumer ecommerce. Ask for direct references, ideally from a company in a similar market. Be wary of proof that consists only of AI answer screenshots. Credible proof shows the prompt, the date, and what happened to leads afterward.

9. How Often Will the Agency Report and Communicate?

AI search changes quickly, and the reporting rhythm should keep pace. Ask who the main contact is and how often progress reviews happen. Also ask how the strategy adjusts when AI platforms change how they cite sources. A solid answer includes a named contact and a fixed review schedule, such as monthly calls. It also defines a clear route for urgent issues. Reports should explain what changed, why it matters, and what happens next, not just list numbers. Regular check-ins also keep sales, marketing, and leadership aligned when everyone wants answers about AI visibility. We put this in writing. Our 90-Day Delivery Guarantee includes a dated plan and monthly reports. Clients always know what we did and what’s next.

10. What Timeline Is Realistic?

Honest providers give ranges, not promises. Timelines depend on competition, industry complexity, current site structure, and how much useful content already exists. A realistic answer breaks the timeline into stages. An agency can complete technical fixes and schema updates early. New content needs time to be crawled, indexed, and picked up by AI tools. Authority building, such as earning mentions on industry sites, takes longer still. Ask what results to expect at 30, 90, and 180 days. Also ask which early signals will show progress before leads follow. Be cautious of anyone guaranteeing a ChatGPT citation or a fixed spot in AI Overviews. No provider controls those outputs.

Quick Reference: Strong Answers vs. Red Flags

Use this table during agency calls to compare answers side by side.
Question to Ask What a Strong Answer Includes Red Flag
1. How does the agency define AEO, GEO, and AI SEO? Clear, separate definitions tied to one plan Terms used interchangeably
2. Which AI platforms will the agency track? Named platforms and prompts built from real buyer questions Brand-name checks on a single tool
3. How will the agency measure success? Mentions, citations, share of voice, accuracy, and leads Keyword rankings only
4. Does the agency start with an audit and competitor gap analysis? A documented audit with prioritized fixes A fixed package before any research
5. How will the agency handle entity and structured data work? Named schema types and ongoing consistency checks No mention of entities or directories
6. What does the agency’s content approach look like? Question-led, accurate, industry-specific content High volumes of generic posts
7. Will the agency keep the traditional SEO foundation strong? One program covering SEO and AI visibility AI SEO pitched as a replacement for SEO
8. Can the agency show results for similar B2B businesses? Named case studies, references, and honest labeling Screenshots with no context or outcomes
9. How often will the agency report and communicate? A named contact, a fixed schedule, and clear next steps Numbers with no explanation
10. What timeline is realistic? Staged ranges with early milestones Guaranteed ChatGPT citations or AI Overview spots

Choosing the Right AI SEO Agency for a B2B Business

Hiring well comes down to method, measurement, and honesty. A provider that answers these ten questions clearly is more likely to build lasting visibility. Put the same questions to every agency on the shortlist and compare the answers side by side. Look for specifics: named platforms, real prompts, sample reports, and honest timelines. Vague answers during the sales process rarely get clearer after the contract is signed. These are the standards we hold ourselves to. MacRAE’S Blue Book has been the trusted source industrial buyers turn to for over a century. We’ve applied that insight to digital marketing and SEO for more than 25 years. That SEO foundation supports all of our AI visibility work. Our clients rate us 4.9 out of 5 across 35 Google Reviews. As an AI SEO company built for B2B, we offer a free strategy session. It shows where a business appears in AI search today and what closing the gaps will take.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does an AI SEO agency cost?

Pricing depends on scope, competition, the number of AI platforms tracked, and content needs. Ask for a written proposal that ties every cost to a specific deliverable.

No. AI platforms decide what they cite. A credible provider strengthens the signals that make citation more likely and reports progress honestly.

Usually not. AEO relies on the same technical foundation, authority, and content as SEO. One coordinated program avoids gaps and conflicting work.

We build AI SEO on three pillars: SEO, GEO, and conversions. We deliver them through our AI Visibility Engine™. The work fits the technical language and long sales cycles of B2B buyers.

For our clients, initial improvements in clarity and visibility typically begin within 3 to 6 months. Timing depends on competition, industry complexity, and existing site structure.

Author

Tanvir Singh Chawla

Tanvir Singh Chawla is an accomplished sales and marketing leader with over eight years of experience across the automotive and digital marketing industries. Currently the Digital Strategy Lead at MacRAE’S Digital Marketing Agency, Tanvir specializes in developing and executing high-impact digital strategies, demand generation campaigns, and client success ... Read More

Contact us to explore how we can help your business grow.